Empirical Literature Review — What a Wilmington Trial Found When Teenagers Received Cash Assistance

Christina Plerhoples Stacy, Daniel Teles and colleagues’ 2024 Journal of Urban Health study examined cash assistance for young men aged 14 to 17 in Wilmington, Delaware. The randomized trial included 167 participants after dropouts. It compared $150 weekly for six months, a payment paired with programming and initial attendance requirements, and a waitlisted control group. Cash alone improved a composite measure of healthy behaviors. The combined intervention improved a secondary measure of financial health. Neither intervention produced a statistically significant change in criminal justice engagement, and researchers found no increase in spending on alcohol, tobacco, marijuana or other drugs. The study therefore gives practitioners evidence about particular outcomes while leaving the central question of violence reduction unresolved.

The trial’s small sample and wide confidence intervals limit what can be concluded about effects that were not statistically significant. Participation also fell short of the recruitment target during the pandemic. For community-safety organizations, the study offers a useful model of evaluation. It separates financial support from the additional program requirements that institutions often attach to assistance. A local funder could use that distinction to examine whether the conditions it imposes improve participation or merely determine who can obtain help. Future evaluations should measure violence exposure directly, preserve young people’s accounts of the barriers they face and assess whether improvements continue after payments end. The research invites a more precise discussion of what material assistance accomplishes and which outcomes require further study.

Sources Cited

Categories: , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *