Adam Dale Newman Williams, Nina Jacob, Detelina Grozeva, and colleagues examined the feasibility of a randomized trial of Critical Time Intervention for men leaving prison at risk of homelessness. Published in BMJ Open in 2025, the PHaCT study combined a pilot trial with process and exploratory economic evaluations. The intervention began before release and continued through stages of intensive support, increasing independence, and transfer to community providers. Although recruitment was planned across four prisons in England and Wales, only three contributed participants. Thirty-four of 37 people approached consented, but enrollment fell well short of the target of 80, and only six participants provided follow-up data. The central finding concerns feasibility: strong initial willingness to participate did not translate into sustained research contact after release. Staff and participants generally accepted the intervention, while randomization and the trial arrangements raised practical and ethical concerns.
For community-safety practitioners, the study highlights the institutional conditions necessary to maintain support through a disruptive transition. Changes in release arrangements, limited staffing, and difficulties coordinating with probation affected the ability to deliver and evaluate the model. These findings do not establish that the intervention reduced homelessness, improved health, or prevented offending; a small feasibility trial with extensive missing follow-up data cannot support those conclusions. Nor should loss of research contact be equated automatically with disengagement from services. Instead, the study provides a reason to build reliable communication, continuity of personnel, and appropriate research arrangements into programs before scaling them. Its relevance to American reentry policy is analytical rather than a direct estimate of local effects: housing assistance requires an institutional structure capable of sustaining relationships after release, and evaluations must account for the conditions under which those relationships are maintained.



Leave a Reply