The Racial Grief Gap: Healing is the Priority

For young Black and brown men, a community-safety agenda must account for the people living with the aftermath of violence.

A homicide leaves people behind whose lives will never return to what they were. A mother must learn to live without her son. A brother loses someone who shared his childhood. Friends confront an empty seat, an unanswered message, and a future that no longer includes someone they expected to grow old with. Public attention may move on after the investigation or funeral. The people carrying the loss must continue attending school, working, raising children, and finding a way to live.

For young Black and brown men, community-safety must include room to discuss that aftermath. We need to ask who they have lost, how often loss has interrupted their lives, and whether anyone has made space for them to grieve. A safety agenda that counts deaths while overlooking the needs of survivors provides an incomplete account of what violence takes from a community.

The racial grief gap describes an inequality in the conditions surrounding loss: who experiences bereavement, how early and repeatedly it occurs, whether death arrives through violence, and what support is available afterward. This framework does not presume that Black and brown people possess a different capacity to grieve. It asks how unequal exposure and unequal resources shape the burden people must carry.

Research supports taking that question seriously. In a 2017 study using nationally representative longitudinal data, Debra Umberson and colleagues documented substantial Black-White disparities in exposure to family deaths across the life course. Their findings direct attention to the survivors of unequal mortality. A premature death takes a life and also changes the relationships, responsibilities, and resources of those who remain.

The disparities are especially stark for homicide. CDC surveillance for 2023 reported homicide rates of 50.6 per 100,000 among Black males, 10.7 among Hispanic males, and 3.5 among White males. These figures concern people killed, rather than the number of people bereaved, but they establish a sharply unequal distribution of lethal violence. The patterns differ across causes of death, so homicide disparities should not be generalized to every category of unnatural death. Black and brown communities are also diverse, and research on Black Americans cannot automatically describe every other population.

Grief deserves attention whether or not it meets the criteria for a psychiatric diagnosis. The American Psychiatric Association distinguishes ordinary bereavement from prolonged grief disorder, or PGD, which involves persistent, intense grief accompanied by significant distress or impairment beyond cultural expectations. For adults, diagnosis requires that the death occurred at least 12 months earlier. That diagnostic threshold should never become a waiting period for practical support, companionship, or care.

An influential 2008 study by B. Goldsmith and colleagues found PGD in 21% of African American participants, compared with 12% of White participants. Those figures represented 14 of 66 African American participants and 55 of 471 White participants across two bereaved samples. Sudden or unexpected death was also associated with PGD. The findings identified a disparity worth investigating, but they were not national population estimates and preceded the current DSM-5-TR diagnosis.

More recent evidence adds detail. In a study published online in 2023 and in a 2024 journal issue, Jasmine R. Jamison-Petr and Joah L. Williams examined 259 participants in research focused on Black bereavement. They reported that 34% of the sample met PGD criteria on the self-report PG-13 measure. Younger age, prior trauma exposure, and violent death were associated with grief symptoms; after accounting for co-occurring mental health symptoms, PTSD and anxiety symptoms remained significant. The 34% figure applies to that sample, not Black Americans nationally, and differences in samples and measures prevent treating it as an increase from the 2008 estimate.

Treatment research also offers grounds for hope. A 2025 study by Margaret Gacheru and colleagues analyzed 55 Black and 455 White adults from two randomized clinical trials. Both groups had higher treatment-response rates with PGD-targeted psychotherapy than with comparison treatment. The investigators found no significant racial difference in baseline grief severity or impairment, although Black participants reported less tangible social support. These were participants already experiencing PGD, so the study does not estimate racial differences in prevalence. It does show why access to effective grief treatment belongs in the discussion.

Other recent findings require careful interpretation. In 2024, Alyssa A. Rheingold and colleagues reported probable PGD in 20.4% of 1,529 bereaved survey respondents. The proportion was 23.7% among those reporting traumatic loss and 13.8% among those reporting natural loss. Their adjusted regression found no statistically significant Black-White difference. The adjustment included demographics and loss characteristics, including a binary category that grouped homicide, motor vehicle crashes, overdose, and suicide as traumatic deaths. The survey used predetermined recruitment targets for loss groups, rather than a population-representative sample of bereavement exposure.

For evaluating the racial grief gap, this creates a consequential limitation. Holding loss circumstances constant asks whether an association with race remains among people with comparable measured circumstances. It cannot establish equality in the overall burden generated by unequal exposure to death. If racialized conditions increase exposure to traumatic bereavement, adjusting for that exposure can set aside part of the pathway through which inequality operates. This is a potential overadjustment concern for the broader disparity question, rather than proof that the study’s calculation was erroneous. Demonstrating how much adjustment changed its racial estimate would require additional analysis.

A simple hypothetical example illustrates the distinction. If 300 people in one population experience traumatic bereavement and 100 in another do, a 20% PGD rate among the bereaved would produce 60 cases in the first population and 20 in the second. The conditional rate is identical; the population burden is three times greater. An adjusted finding of no racial association therefore cannot, by itself, refute a racial grief gap. Nor does grouping several traumatic causes together fully capture the circumstances of homicide bereavement, continuing threats, or successive losses.

A 2026 medical-record study by Jessica Kuo and colleagues likewise needs to be read within its limits. Among 2,464 patients with recorded PGD diagnoses, 19.1% were Black, compared with 19.9% of bereaved comparison patients, a nonsignificant difference. Those percentages describe the composition of clinical groups, not the prevalence of PGD among Black Americans. Recorded diagnoses depend on people reaching care and having the condition recognized. Such data cannot settle the question of unmet grief needs outside clinical settings.

Taken together, these studies support a more careful public conversation. The racial grief gap does not depend on proving that race independently predicts PGD after every loss circumstance is held constant. It concerns the distribution of loss, the accumulation of its consequences, and the opportunity to heal. A person can experience profound bereavement without a disorder. A community can carry an unequal grief burden even when its members have the same probability of PGD after comparable losses.

For young men, that conversation should allow many forms of expression. Some may want to talk; others may first connect through music, art, sport, spiritual practice, or shared remembrance. Schools and service providers should create opportunities to ask about loss when a young person struggles, while avoiding assumptions that anger, silence, or withdrawal necessarily indicate trauma. Grieving young men deserve support because their lives and relationships matter. They should not have to be labeled dangerous, disruptive, or clinically ill before help becomes available.

A community-safety response should make bereavement support reachable after a killing and sustain it beyond the funeral. Cities can fund trusted organizations to offer voluntary outreach to relatives, friends, classmates, and peers; practical assistance with funeral expenses, transportation, and benefits; and clear routes to qualified grief and trauma clinicians. Credible messengers, faith leaders, coaches, and peer supporters can help people connect with care when properly trained, compensated, and supported. Their relationships should complement clinical expertise, with clear boundaries and referral options.

Institutions should also make everyday life more manageable after loss. Schools can provide flexible deadlines and supported returns to class. Employers can recognize that a close friend or extended relative may be central to someone’s life. Funders can support continuity rather than brief projects that disappear while families are still grieving. Evaluations should examine whether people receive timely help, remain connected to education and work, and report support that respects their needs and choices. Programs should also test their outcomes rather than assume that grief services alone reduce violence.

Finally, prevention and healing must advance together. Housing stability, accessible health care, economic opportunity, safe places for young people, and efforts to prevent violence belong alongside bereavement services in a comprehensive community-safety agenda. Counseling cannot replace investment in the conditions that make life safer. Preventing a death protects the person at risk and the relationships that would otherwise be broken by that loss.

The racial grief gap calls on public institutions to recognize what mortality statistics leave behind. Every life lost belonged to a network of people, and those people deserve more than an expectation of resilience. A community-safety agenda should seek to prevent premature death, recognize cumulative bereavement, and make sustained support available to survivors. The responsibility to protect life includes a responsibility to help people live after loss.

Sources Cited

Goldsmith, B., R. S. Morrison, L. C. Vanderwerker, and H. G. Prigerson. 2008. Elevated Rates of Prolonged Grief Disorder in African Americans. Death Studies 32 (4): 352-365. https://doi.org/10.1080/07481180801929012

Jamison-Petr, Jasmine R., and Joah L. Williams. 2024. Understanding Black and African American Grief Following Inclusion of Prolonged Grief Disorder in the DSM-5-TR. Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities 11: 2627-2637. First published online August 1, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40615-023-01727-x

Gacheru, Margaret, et al. 2025. Exploring Differences in Presentation and Treatment Outcomes Between Black and White American Adults With Prolonged Grief Disorder. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice 32 (1): 44-55. First published online July 30, 2024. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cbpra.2024.05.004

Rheingold, Alyssa A., Joah L. Williams, and Jamison S. Bottomley. 2024. Prevalence and Co-Occurrence of Psychiatric Conditions Among Bereaved Adults. JAMA Network Open 7 (6): e2415325. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.15325

Kuo, Jessica, Nathan Lebens, and Eduardo D. Espiridion. 2026. Associated Comorbidities and Clinical Features of Prolonged Grief Disorder Diagnosis Among Bereaved Individuals: A Retrospective Electronic Health Record (EHR)-Based Cohort Study Using TriNetX. Cureus 18 (3): e105320. https://doi.org/10.7759/cureus.105320

Umberson, Debra, Julie Skalamera Olson, Robert Crosnoe, Hui Liu, Tetyana Pudrovska, and Rachel Donnelly. 2017. Death of Family Members as an Overlooked Source of Racial Disadvantage in the United States. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114 (5): 915-920. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1605599114

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2026. Surveillance for Violent Deaths: National Violent Death Reporting System, 50 States, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico, 2023. MMWR Surveillance Summaries 75 (7). https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/75/ss/ss7507a1.htm

American Psychiatric Association. Prolonged Grief Disorder. Patient and family information. https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/prolonged-grief-disorder/

Categories:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *